The truth about closing clients via email: Most agencies don't lose deals because of bad proposals. They lose them because of bad follow-up timing, weak subject lines, and not having a clear template for the awkward moments.
These 7 templates cover every stage — from the first intro to the "I'll think about it" objection to the re-engagement months later. Copy, paste, personalize the orange fields, and send.
Use when: reaching out cold to a potential client
To:[FirstName] <email@company.com>
Subject:quick question about [CompanyName]'s email
Hi [FirstName],
Noticed [CompanyName] recently [specific thing — launched a product/hired/raised funding]. Congrats on that.
Quick question: how are you currently handling follow-ups to leads that don't reply the first time?
I ask because most agencies I talk to are losing 2–3 clients a month not from bad proposals, but from follow-ups that get buried.
We built a tool that handles this automatically. Happy to show you in a 10-min call — or just reply with how you're doing it now and I'll share what's working.
— [YourName]
✓ Avg 34% reply rate when personalized correctly
Key: The subject line uses their company name and "quick question" — it reads like a human wrote it, not a campaign. The body ends with a low-commitment ask.
Use when: prospect hasn't replied 2 days after your first email
To:[FirstName]
Subject:Re: quick question about [CompanyName]'s email
Hey [FirstName],
Just bumping this up — I know inboxes get busy.
One thing that might be relevant: [specific pain point for their industry].
If now isn't the right time, just say so — I won't follow up again unless it's useful.
— [YourName]
✓ Recovers 22% of non-responses from email 1
Key: Short. Gives them a way out ("just say so"). That permission paradoxically makes people more likely to reply positively.
Use when: you sent a proposal and haven't heard back in 3 days
To:[FirstName]
Subject:[ProjectName] proposal — any questions?
Hi [FirstName],
Wanted to follow up on the proposal I sent over for [project].
If you have any questions about the scope, timeline, or pricing, happy to jump on a quick call to walk through it — or just reply here.
Also: if the budget or timing doesn't work right now, let me know. I'd rather find a fit that works for both of us than have it sit unresolved.
Looking forward to hearing your thoughts.
— [YourName]
✓ Gets a response (yes or no) 67% of the time
Key: Asking "any questions?" is softer than "what did you think?" The last paragraph signals you're not desperate — you're collaborative.
Use when: prospect said they need time to decide
To:[FirstName]
Subject:Re: [ProjectName]
Of course — take the time you need.
Two things that might help you decide:
1. [Specific result you got for a similar client — "We helped [Agency X] cut their proposal-to-close time by 40% in 6 weeks"]
2. I have one spot available starting [date 3 weeks out]. After that, the next opening is [6-8 weeks out].
If it helps, I'm also happy to start with a smaller scope — [reduced-scope option] — so you can see the work before committing to the full project.
Let me know either way.
— [YourName]
✓ Closes 38% of "thinking about it" prospects within 7 days
Key: Social proof + real scarcity (not fake) + a smaller commitment option. Three tools, one email. Never push — create clarity.
Use when: prospect says your price is too high
To:[FirstName]
Subject:Re: [ProjectName]
I hear you — $X,XXX is a real investment.
A few options that might help:
Option A — Start smaller: We could begin with just [phase 1 deliverable] at $X,XXX. If the results are there, we expand from that foundation.
Option B — Phased payments: Same scope, split into 3 monthly payments of $X,XXX.
Option C — Adjusted scope: If there's a specific part of the proposal that's less critical, I can trim it and bring the investment down to $X,XXX.
Which of those feels closest to what works for you?
— [YourName]
✓ Saves 45% of deals that would otherwise be lost on price
Key: Never drop price immediately. Give them 3 paths — they choose. This reframes from "negotiate" to "configure" which preserves your value.
Use when: a warm lead has gone completely silent for 1–3 months
To:[FirstName]
Subject:closing the loop
Hi [FirstName],
We spoke a while back about [the project] and I never heard back — totally understand, things get busy.
I'm closing out my open threads and wanted to check: is this still something on your radar, or should I mark it as closed on my end?
No pressure either way — genuinely just want to keep things clean.
— [YourName]
✓ Gets a reply from 41% of ghosted prospects
Key: "Closing the loop" and "mark it closed" are pattern interrupts. You're giving them permission to say no, which paradoxically makes yes easier. This email gets replies like "oh sorry, yes let's talk".
Use when: you've completed a project and the client is happy
To:[ClientName]
Subject:a quick favor
Hi [ClientName],
Really glad we got to work together on [project] — the results speak for themselves.
Quick ask: do you know one or two other [type of business] owners who are dealing with similar challenges? The kind of people who'd benefit from the same approach?
If so, a quick intro email from you is worth more than any ad I could ever run. I'll take it from there.
And of course — if there's ever anything I can do for you, I'm always happy to return the favor.
— [YourName]
✓ 1 in 3 happy clients will make an intro when asked this way
Key: Ask for a specific type of referral (not "anyone you know"). Acknowledge the value of their word-of-mouth. Offer reciprocity. Timing matters — send this within 48 hours of a win.
Now put them to work automatically
Stop sending these manually
MailMaster runs these templates automatically — the right email goes out at the right time, whether you're in a meeting or asleep. One-time $349. No subscription.
Get MailMaster — from $349 →
Lifetime license · Mac & Windows · Connects Gmail, Outlook & more